Judges Criteria Overview

Posted on

Judges Criteria

******** SCORING OVERVIEW ********

Below is an overview of some of the criteria the judges utilize when they are scoring an entry.

Judges score the film using a numerical value for each of the elements (below) that they review.  Once all elements have been scored  – they are added up and the total score determines if the film qualifies for an award.  The different award levels are determined by the total score.

Slight adjustments to the numerical scoring are made for students (based on their grade level) and for filmmakers 17-years and under.

******** ALL ENTRIES ********

Cinematography / Focus – Shots are all in focus- 100% of the film. Creativity in shot list, angles and scenes. Scenes are filmed at the correct exposure. Exposure is consistent throughout the piece.  (of course – some consideration is given for “run-and-gun” on the scene shots that may have a focus issue or two – but shots should be in focus the majority of the time)  The subject in all of the set-up interviews is sharp and in focus.

Audio – The audio is clear, clean, leveled, not over-modulated and consistent throughout the film. There are no obvious dubs. No obvious sound differences between characters in the same scene or between scenes due to different microphones or microphone levels.

Sound mix – All dialog, soundtrack and under-bed music tracks are crisp, clear (no unintended hiss, echo or artifact sounds) and at the correct volume levels to adequately hear the dialog over the music or sounds. All foley and background sounds are appropriate and well done.

Music – The music is appropriate to the film delivering the right emotion for the scene. It is at the correct levels throughout the piece and does not spike disproportionately at any point. It never overpowers the dialog.

Editing – The piece is put together with appropriately timed elements. Special effects and transitions are used fittingly for the piece. No cuts are made in mid dialog or musical beats.

Lighting – The lighting is even at all times with no dark or overblown spots. If there are night or dark scenes – the subjects are still easily visible to the viewer. The subjects are always well lit to be visible to the viewer in each and every scene.

Color – The color is consistent and realistic throughout the whole film (or consistent with intentional color design and styling throughout the piece).

Emotional Impact – The film clearly elicits the desired emotional response from the viewer.

Green Screen – For all scenes involving green screen –  the edges of the subject are clean with no obvious artifacts from background removal. The background image is in appropriate size, aspect ratio and perspective. The subject and background are well lit to seamlessly blend together.

Background images / stock footage – All background images are sharp, lit in the same temperature as the rest of the piece and no “watermark” from the company selling the background images / footage is visible.  The stock footage is appropriate for the script accurately reflecting the time / place / message of the scene.

Film Crew – The crew of the film are never “accidentally” seen in the shot (IE: in scenes that have mirrors, window glass or other reflective surfaces), the boom mic is never seen anywhere in the frame, etc.

Script – The script is well laid out to deliver the message of the piece and well written to support plot lines or information.

Message Clarity – The intention is understood by the viewer. The piece must not be so esoteric that it can only be understood by reading the notes. Even experimental and avant-garde films must be ultimately fully understood by the viewer with no additional explanation required.

Direction – The film flows at an appropriate pace, the on-camera talent and locations are carefully chosen and utilized to deliver the intention of the scene (or places and interviewees for a doc), the scenes flow appropriately between takes. The artistic and dramatic aspects are consistent and the technical crew carry out the vision.

******** NON-FICTION / DOCUMENTARY ********

Tight Narrative – The intention / vision for the piece is clear, strong and informs every creative and editorial step to stay on point with the message.

Message – There is a clear and compelling message that drives all aspects of the film and is clear to the viewer.

Set-Up – The film is well laid out with an over-arching theme supported by the film’s story-lines and scenes. There is a clear and compelling initial set-up that guides the viewers, not just a series of shots edited together with no set up or consistent threads that weave the story together.

Length – The film is tightly woven and presented in the shortest time possible to fully illustrate the story. No extraneous / unnecessary scenes that do not support the narrative.

Reconstructions – The film portrays reconstructions of events in a professional and interesting way with appropriate period costumes and details.

Overarching Theme / Purpose – The film portrays more than just an interesting subject (person) and asks a broader question or illustrates a bigger viewpoint.

Research – The film is well researched and thoroughly presents the issues. If there are multiple sides they are presented.

Narration – The narration is professional with appropriate inflection and cadence. The audio mix is appropriate with narration clearly heard above under-beds or music levels.

On Camera talent – The on-camera talent is professional and easy to understand. No obvious teleprompter reading and talent is never seen obviously looking at prompter or other cues.

Focus – All of the subject interviews are in focus during the entire interview.  The subject’s face is the focus – not an accidental focus on something in the background.

Special effects – Are professional and well done. Not overused and distracting to the story-line.

******** OBJECTIVE REVIEW ********

It is helpful to receive objective reviews and feedback for your film.  It is normal for a filmmaker to be attached to their piece and to have put so much of their time, energy and passion into it – that it might be harder to be objective about the final produced piece.   We recommend enlisting a completely impartial person to deliver honest feedback.  (Of course, we all love our family and friends and lean on them to give us feedback in our endeavors – though they are often not as impartial a source of feedback as you might be seeking)